If I had my druthers (whatever those are), I’d double the national science budget and spend 100% of the added amount re-grilling scientists and replicating important studies to check the outcomes of some percentage of them.
This is actually 2 issues that can overlap but don’t have to.
Reproducibility, which may not be possible for some older (and even new) papers because not enough information was given to really replicate data again or in the case of some life sciences research, material was used that is not available any more in this form.
Scientific misconduct, which is not reproducible because, well, it’s not real.
Ah, I meant grilling as in going back to scientists who redacted or withdrew publications or published results that subsequently couldn’t be reproduced to determine whether the issue was fear of publishing an uninteresting result, some kind of consensus pressure, or actual experimental error that was only found later. Not so much looking for misconduct.
If I had my druthers (whatever those are), I’d double the national science budget and spend 100% of the added amount re-grilling scientists and replicating important studies to check the outcomes of some percentage of them.
This is actually 2 issues that can overlap but don’t have to.
Reproducibility, which may not be possible for some older (and even new) papers because not enough information was given to really replicate data again or in the case of some life sciences research, material was used that is not available any more in this form.
Scientific misconduct, which is not reproducible because, well, it’s not real.
Ah, I meant grilling as in going back to scientists who redacted or withdrew publications or published results that subsequently couldn’t be reproduced to determine whether the issue was fear of publishing an uninteresting result, some kind of consensus pressure, or actual experimental error that was only found later. Not so much looking for misconduct.