Smiling may not always make you happier, and new research suggests that forcing yourself to smile repeatedly could actually make you feel worse. In a University of Florida study involving more than 1,100 participants, researchers discovered that while a single artificial smile can provide a small mood boost, repeatedly faking smiles can erase that benefit or even reverse it.



File this under No Shit, Sherlock.
Faking positive emotions really needs to be driven out of cultural expectation.
Where do all these “no shit” studies even come from? Not only is this one “no shit,” it deals with such vague and subjective things like smiling and happiness that it doesn’t even seem like a good topic for scientific inquiry.
Pretty sure some of the come from doctoral students. In some (all?) institutions you have to do original research to earn your degree, but the school owns what you create, so there’s no point giving away your best ideas for free.
“researchers discovered that while a single artificial smile can provide a small mood boost, repeatedly faking smiles can erase that benefit or even reverse it.”
Nuance needs to be driven into cultural expectation.
Easy logic. Smile associated with good. When smile a lot during bad, smile associated with bad
I wouldn’t consider this common sense at all. Growing up, I was always taught that faking a smile can produce dopamine and legitimately make you happier.
It’s good that things like this actually get researched.
If only the research was also read! They found that smiling DOES do that in the short term. It’s only long term repeated economic pressure to keep it up which is depressing.
But USians were arguing with me just some days ago that forced smiles make them cheery.
This stuff is so slippery I don’t see how we can ever get objective truths out of it. Trying to have a more positive attitude can absolutely make you feel better. How do you separate that out from people who consciously try to make themselves smile so they’ll feel better?
My dude, I’ve had a copy of ‘The Secret’ at my family’s home when I was but a wee teenager, and as could be expected its teachings did nothing to me or to anyone else that I’ve seen. On the other hand, mindfulness and vaguely related practices, namely meditation, did me wonders — particularly because tenseness and irritation/anxiety produce each other in a loop, and other bodily conditions like hunger influence the mind a lot.
Which is to say, we can tell horseshit that doesn’t work from helpful practices that do. Not once did empty smiling helped me in anything (since thankfully I’m not in a culture that values it), whereas genuine smiles caused by people with whom I like to be joyful, signified joy. I’ve known people way into their twilight years, in whose face one could see the many years of genuine smiles by the wrinkles that they cause, and who were a delight to be around. The very fact that ‘empty smile’ is an expression, should tell you all you need to know.
You try to have a positive attitude by changing how you feel, not how you look. Take a gawk into Zen, it’ll do you good. And contrary to what someone claimed in the linked thread, I’ve never seen bullshit smiles recommended in Zen.
This. ⬆️
No Shit, Sherlock. I’m surprised it needed a study.
It’s really important to study the obvious things. Most provide evidence of things we knew so we can be confident, and some prove common sense wrong and improve our understanding of the world.