

Sure, probably true. We’ve detected a lot of dark matter actually! Based on a bunch of things, we expect the universe to have more matter than we actually observe. Dark matter just refers to any mass that falls into that category of “previously unobserved”. So as we discover that there are more black holes than we thought, as our telescopes become capable of detecting extremely dim brown dwarves, and as we discover new subatomic particles, we chip away at dark matter, finally shining a light over previously hidden areas of our universe.
But there’s still more unaccounted for.
Your not wrong exactly. The theories hold up perfectly, they work consistently at many different scales. But at the largest scales, when looking at galaxies, or the universe as a whole, the theories don’t hold up. Or, they would hold up, if the galaxies had more mass in them than we can see… So the simplest explanation is that we’re not actually seeing all the mass that’s there.
That has turned out to be right so far. By that I mean, we have found a whole bunch more matter that was previously unaccounted for. We just haven’t found enough of it yet to fill in all the gaps.
But yeah, we stick with the dark matter idea because it has sort of panned out so far - we have found more stuff.