

It honestly depends on a huge multitude of factors. ACV is one of them, but a low cost generally means a lower rate. Collision is almost always more expensive than comp.
Collision: anything you hit while moving (another car, a pedestrian, a tree, a pole, an adnominal in the road) <–things that would otherwise be avoidable.
Comprehensive: “Act of God” stuff (lightning strike, tree limb falls on it, theft, an animal actively jumping out in front of you, hail damage) <–not likely to affect your rates for claims since it’s near unavoidable.
If a truck blew out a tire and it rolls into your lane and you hit it: comprehensive. If the tire blows out and other cars swerve to miss it laying there, but you hit it: collision.
Fuck this system! Under Trump, it makes even more sense why he rolled back regulations on coal and natural gas usage instead of pushing green. He has so many puppeteer hands shoved so far up his ass its amazing he can still form a coherent sentence!